Note: I expect to update this post over time. Last update: 8/22/2019.
As our new Edge Insider builds roll out to the public, we’re starting to triage reports of compatibility issues where Edge76 (the new Chromium-based Edge, aka Anaheim) behaves differently than the old Edge (Edge18, aka Spartan) and/or Google Chrome.
In general, Edge76 will behave very similarly to Chrome, with the caveat that, to date, only Dev and Canary channels have been released. When looking at Chrome behavior, be sure to compare against the corresponding Chrome Dev and Canary channels.
However, we expect there will be some behavioral deltas between Edge76 and its Chrome-peer versions, so I’ll note those here too.
Note: I’ve previously blogged about interop issues between Edge18 and Chrome.
- For security reasons, Edge76 and Chrome block navigation to file:// URLs from non-file URLs. If a browser user clicks on a file: link on a webpage, nothing happens (except an error message in the Developer Tools console, noting “Not allowed to load local resource: file://host/whatever”). In contrast, Edge18 (like Internet Explorer before it) allowed HTTP/HTTPS-served pages in your Intranet Zone to navigate to URLs that use the file:// URL protocol; only pages in the Internet Zone were blocked from such navigations. No override for this block is available.
- Unlike IE/Edge18, Edge76/Chrome do not support DirectInvoke, a scheme whereby a download is converted into the launch of an application with a URL argument. DirectInvoke is most commonly used when launching Office documents and when running ClickOnce applications. For now, users can workaround the lack of ClickOnce support by installing an extension.
- Edge76/Chrome do not support the proprietary msSaveBlob or msSaveOrOpenBlob APIs supported in Edge18. In most cases, you should instead use an A element with a download attribute.
- Edge18 did not support navigation to or downloading from data URLs via the download attribute; Edge76/Chrome allow the download of data URLs up to 2mb in length. In most cases, you should prefer blob urls.
HTTPS – TLS Protocol
- Edge76 and Chrome enable TLS/1.3 by default; Edge18 does not support TLS/1.3 prior to Windows 10 19H1, and even on that platform it is disabled by default (and known to be buggy).
- Edge76 and Chrome support a different list of TLS ciphers than Edge18.
- Edge76 and Chrome send GREASE tokens in HTTPS handshakes; Edge18 does not.
- Edge76 and Chrome prohibit connections for HTTP/2 traffic from using banned (weak) ciphers, showing ERR_SPDY_INADEQUATE_TRANSPORT_SECURITY if the server attempts to use such ciphers. Edge18 did not enforce this requirement. This has primarily impacted intranet websites served by IIS on Windows Server 2012 where the server was either misconfigured or does not have the latest updates installed. Patching the server and/or adjusting its TLS configuration will resolve the problem.
HTTPS – Certificates
- Edge76 and Chrome require that a site’s certificate contain its domain name in the SubjectAltName (SAN) field. Edge 18 permits the certificate to omit the SAN and if the domain name is in the Subject Common Name (CN) field. (All public CAs use the SAN; certificates that chain to a local/enterprise trusted root may need to be updated).
- Edge76 and Chrome require certificates that chain to trusted root CAs to be logged in Certificate Transparency (CT). This generally isn’t a problem because public roots are supposed to log in CT as a part of their baseline requirements. However, certain organizations (including Microsoft and CAs) have hybrid roots which are both publicly trusted and issue privately within the organization. As a result, loading pages may error out with NET::ERR_CERTIFICATE_TRANSPARENCY_REQUIRED. To mitigate this, such organizations must either start logging internal certificates in CT, or set one of three policies under HKLM\SOFTWARE\Policies\Microsoft\Edge\. Edge18 does not support CT.
- Edge76 and Chrome use a custom Win32 client certificate picker UI, while Edge18 uses the system’s default certificate picker.
- Edge76 and Chrome support the Leave Secure Cookies Alone spec, which blocks HTTP pages from setting cookies with the Secure attribute and restricts the ways in which HTTP pages may interfere with cookies sent to HTTPS pages. Legacy Edge does not have these restrictions.
- Edge76 and Chrome support Cookie prefixes (restrictions on cookies whose names begin with the prefixes __Secure- and __Host-). Legacy Edge does not enforce these restrictions.
- Edge76, Chrome, and Firefox ignore Set-Cookie headers with values over 4096 characters in length (including cookie-controlling directives like SameSite). In contrast, IE and Edge18 permit cookies with name-value pairs up to 5118 characters in length.
Authentication and Login
- In Edge76, Edge18, and Firefox, running the browser in InPrivate mode disables automatic Integrated Windows Authentication. Chrome and Internet Explorer do not disable automatic authentication in private mode. You can disable automatic authentication in Chrome by launching it with a command line argument:
- Edge18/Edge76 integrates a built-in single-sign-on (SSO) provider, such that configured account credentials are automatically injected into request headers for configured domains; this feature is disabled in InPrivate mode. Chrome does not have this behavior for Microsoft accounts.
- Edge18 supports Azure Active Directory’s Conditional Access feature. For Chrome, an extension is required. Edge76 has not yet integrated support for this feature.
- Edge18 includes an API window.external.GetHostEnvironmentValue that returns some interesting information about the system, including whether it is running in the “Windows 10 S” lockdown mode. Edge76 and Chrome do not support this API.Update: Edge 78 restored this API with a limited set of tokens:
- Google Chrome ships with the Portable Native Client plugin; Edge76 does not include this plugin. The plugin is little-used and you’re unlikely to encounter problems with its absence except on the Google Earth website. PNaCl is deprecated in favor of WebAssembly and is slated to be removed from Chrome in Q2 2019.
- The Edge Platform Status site also includes a short list of features that are supported in Edge18 but not Chromium-derived browsers.
Group Policy and Command Line Arguments
By-default, Edge 76 shares almost all of the same Group Policies and command line arguments as Chrome 76.
If you’re using the registry to set a policy for Edge, put it under the
…node instead of under the
If you’re trying to use a Chrome command line argument when launching in the new MSEdge.exe and it’s not working, check whether it has “blacklist” or “whitelist” in the name. If so, we probably renamed it.
For instance, want to tell Edge not to accept a 3DES ciphersuite for TLS? You need to use
….as you would with Chrome.
Browsers identify themselves to servers using a User-Agent header. A top source of compatibility problems is caused by sites that attempt to behave differently based on the User-Agent header and make incorrect assumptions about feature support, or fail to update their checks over time. Please, for the love of the web, avoid User-Agent Detection at all costs!
Chrome User-Agent string:
Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/76.0.3809.100 Safari/537.36
Edge77 Beta (Desktop) User-Agent string:
Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/77.0.3865.19 Safari/537.36 Edg/220.127.116.11
Edge18 User-Agent string:
Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/70.0.3538.102 Safari/537.36 Edge/18.18362
Edge73 Stable (Android) User-Agent string:
Mozilla/5.0 (Linux; Android 10; Pixel 3 XL) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/73.0.3683.90 Mobile Safari/537.36 EdgA/18.104.22.16892
You’ll note that each of the Edge variants uses a different token at the end of the User-Agent string, but the string otherwise matches Chrome versions of the same build. Sites should almost never do anything with the Edge token information– treat Edge like Chrome. Failing to follow this advice almost always leads to bugs.
Sites are so bad about misusing the User-Agent header that Edge76 was forced to introduce a service-driven override list, which you can find at edge://compat/useragent. Alas, even that feature can cause problems in unusual cases. For testing, you can tell Edge to ignore the list by starting it thusly:
Stay compatible out there!